Sunday, August 5, 2012

Grains and Confused



It's very human to make mistakes. That's what proof reading and error checking are for. However, in the course of the conception, planning, and execution of this post I made such a large blunder - one so central to the conception of the piece - that I feel it will be more instructive, or at least more amusing, to make the blunder itself the subject of the post. Before you click away in disgust let me reassure you that the topic is whisky: old and interesting whisky. There will be tasting notes too. This is meant to be an instructive lesson; not simply a train wreck. But I'll let you be the judge of that.

It all started in April when I wrote a review of Compass Box Hedonism - a blended grain whisky product of delicacy, grace, and a delicious and new flavor signature (for me). I decided to make it my business to try distinguished single grain whiskies.  I was perusing the samples available at our friend's The Masters of Malt.  I knew the names of some of the distillers of single grain whisky: North British, Girvan, Cameron Bridge, Strathclyde, and... and... Inchgower? ...Invergordon?  I always get those confused. It's Invergordon. Inchgower is a malt distillery - not a grain distillery.  It is the primary component in Bell's.  I made this error explicitly on Twitter.  I was discussing a particular old 1964 bottling of Invergordon from The Whisky Exchange. I referred to it as Inchgower in a tweet to Stuart Robson and Billy Abbot (@Cowfish) when the latter gently corrected me. As he did so a light went off.  I had selected and purchased my three mature grain samples, tasted them and written notes and even tweeted some of the notes all without realizing that one of the specimens wasn't a grain whisky at all!

Here are my detailed tasting notes for these three samples from Master of Malt.  Read them over and the discussion will resume afterwards:

"North British:

Edinburgh’s last working distillery, widely known as ‘NB’.
North British does its own malting on site using only maize, with a high persentage of green malt.
North British contributes to such top blends as: J&B, Famous Grouse, chives Regal, Lang's and Cutty Sark."

http://www.scotchwhisky.net/distilleries/silent/north_british.htm


North British 20 1991 Single Cask Master Of Malt 55.8% Cask 3225


Distilled on the 22nd January 1991.  Aged in a first fill bourbon barrel.  Bottled in March 2011. A single cask release of 244 bottles.

Color: pale gold

Nose: cake batter, daisies, acetone, cocoa butter and a hint of savory.

Palate: Sweet & light cocoa butter, bubble gum, cotton candy and a wonderful thread of very august and unusual blueberry fruit on the entry. A bright spirity expansion on mid-palate with tangerine notes and then a drying used up chewing gum feeling on the turn to the finish.  The finish is fairly short and gentle - not really a problem. Lovely - particularly on the sweet candy opening.

A splash of water opens things to an ethereally light sweets and blueberry & gum fruits flavor direction. There is a bit more oak in the end of the mid, but remarkably light and fruity.

Delicious and borderline five stars.

****


Inchgower 29 yo Single Cask Master Of Malt 53.9%

Distilled on the 30th June 1982.  Aged in a single refill hogshead for 29 years before bottling on the 22nd November 2011. A release of just 190 numbered bottles, at natural cask strength. 

 Color: Pale gold

Nose: Cotton, linseed, apricots, faint acetone, some floral notes, but in the hazy distance - like wildflower meadows sniffed through an excellent linen suit.  Nosing further I'm getting lemon with the apricot, natural painter's oils, and some noble rot rancio notes.  It's very nice nose: distinctive and unique. Subtle, yet very involving.

Palate: Floral sweet, tangy with rubarb and blueberry with a lacy floral delicate expansion into a more spirity mid palate with notes of toasted coconut and sweet dry hay. The fade sees a gentle herbal complexity replace the sweet and heat. Very little wood, little tannin for such a mature dram.  There's a ton of rich complexity in the opening and then a pretty dramatic contrast with a drier elegant mid and short turn to the finish. There's a long lingering afterglow aspect to the finish however, with a glow of sweet blueberries that fills me with an intoxicated infatuation however.  This one elicits a powerfully loving emotional response in me.

*****

Girvan 45 yo 1965 The Clan Denny (Douglas Liang) 47.3%

Distilled 1965 in refill hogshead number 6276
Grain whisky at Girvan is produced using a mix of 90% wheat and 10% malted barley.

Color: Dark gold meets light amber

Nose: Sweet musk, dried marmelade, flax oil, damp meadow, ghee, marigold, dense dark sultanas, noble rot w/blueberry essence, phenolic solvent and a little distant smoke


Palate: rich and spirity but sweet and complex with dried sultanas in grappa. Oily and dense with rancio and blueberry laced mint, cardamom pods and ivy.  There are also hints of citrus.  That's just the opening!  The expansion brings spice and a bitter medicinal herbal aspect to the full palate of flavors carrying over from the openings.  The finish is a slow gentle fade with most of the same flavors holding.  A rich and august presentation. Flavor dense and sophisticated.

*****


Did you catch my error?  Can you see why I might go the whole day - through the tastings and well after and have to be prompted by a friend before realizing that the Inchgower in question was a malt rather than a grain whisky?  It seemed very much of a piece - down to the unusual blueberry noble rot flavor notes.

Tasting the Inchgower after realizing my error I somehow wasn't getting toasted coconut anymore - I was getting toasted malt instead - modifying those distinctive and fairly unusual rubarb and blueberry flavor notes.   What a lovely sweet and complex entry!  This shift from toasted coconut to toasted malt is a pure example of expectation bias in action.  When I thought it was grain I was wanting to taste coconuts.  When I knew it was malt I wanted malt.  What was I ACTUALLY tasting?  Well tasting is a fusion of neural input and sensory input in the brain.  So the answer is that expectation bias affects what you actually taste.  Both sets of tasting notes are valid.  Thus the power and need for tasting blind.  I can see a clear argument for tasting blind every time.  That doesn't mean I'm going to do it.  The extra effort would be crippling for me in my current circumstances - but I will try to do so as often as I can.

What does this tasting say about mature grains?  Two isn't a definitive sampling - but I can state that these were delicious and that they have big openings and then fade from there - which is quite different than many malts which show a more dramatic evolution across the palate from opening to mid palate to finish.

What does this tasting say about Compass Box Hedonism?  Hedonism seems to be a vatting of grains in the 20s (maybe teens through thirties).  I'll need a lot more experience before I could make anything close to an accurate guess.  Hedonism has many of the flavors of the 20 year old North British but with a smoothness and integrated elegance quite unique all its own.

I think this is the beginning of a beautiful relationship - with mature grain Scotch whiskies... and with error checking.

Friday, August 3, 2012

Highland Queen 1964: An Antique Failure Fails Interestingly

In my quest to taste older whiskies with the complexity that Oliver Klimek discussed in his thought provoking article: "Has Whisky Become Better, Worse or Just Different" I came across the following listing on whiskysamples for an interesting blend bottled in January of 1964:

Thanks to the Belgian customs (never thought I would have to say this) we know this blended whisky was bottled on 20/1/1964 by Macdonald&Muir Ltd., Leith, Scotland.
What the label says: "the basis of this whisky is the matured product of two of the finest malt distilleries in the Scottish Highlands, Glen Moray-Glenlivet and Glenmorangie of which we are the proprietors."

http://whiskysamples.flyingcart.com/index.php?p=detail&pid=618&cat_id=15 

This sounded like a potentially worthy specimen which might display some of the complexity that old whiskies made with in pre-automation days are supposed to display.  Old fashioned "Golden Promise" barley would have been used instead of modern varieties. Wooden washbacks, floor maltings, oven kilns rather than drum, direct fired stills - all those sources of micro variations within a batch that may have resulted in more complex flavors.

A fly in the ointment is that Highland Queen seems limited to this single issue.  (There are plenty of references on the web to this issue - and none to any other).  Why?  Was it a dog product that just didn't taste good, so no further batches were produced?

Update: I'm wrong.  Highland Queen is an old traditional blended Scotch that is still produced.  

"First produced by Roderick MacDonald around 1893 while with Alexander Muir of Lieth. / Highland Queen Blended Scotch Whisky was named in honor of Lieth's connection with Mary Queen of Scots.  Highland Queen consists of 30 - 35 percent malt prodominantly Glen Moray."
http://www.scotchwhisky.net/blended/highland_queen.htm

I see a NAS 40% abv. version of Highland Queen available for sale in Australia ($35) right now.   I also see some 1930s Highland Queen ads on Ebay.


Highland Queen 1964 43%


Color: light gold
Nose: Honey, hay, distant sherry with citrus apricot jam and musk noted, talcum dust and a slight musty mineral note that I'm coming to associate with old whiskies - perhaps a flavor signature of bottle maturation.

Initially sweet with malt and grain sugars, the entry and expansion are disappointingly thin after the nice nose. You can taste some young grain whisky burn. However, tasting beyond the young grain there are some august notes of old style sherried malts with a bit of peat. The finish is medium short with little tannin but some wisps of oak, smoke, and malt. There is some excellent malt here, but buried beneath a young and undistinguished grain whisky.

A few drops of water adds a faint floral note and a bit more apricot on the nose. However it does more on the palate, raising some sweetness and fruity notes that fill in the flat flavor profile. It's no world beater - but the flavors that are present are interesting as old Spey malt flavors - but in diluted form. That degree of flavor dilution may be why this brand only lasted a year.  (Or, as it actually turns out - lasted over a century and still going - as is the actual case).

I can recommend this for a person who wants a whiff of the antique flavor profile - but only in that context.

***

More background to Highland Queen on Gavin Smith & Tom Cannavan's Whisky-Pages blog:

Highland Queen, 12 Year Old (Scotland)
The old-established blended Scotch whisky of Highland Queen, once a staple of the Glenmorangie business, is now part of the Bordeaux-based concern of Picard family (Terroir Distillers), which also owns Tullibardine distillery. A 12-year-old variant of the blend has recently been released to augment the ‘standard’ expression with no age statement. The nose is full and rich, with icing sugar sprinkled on pineapple, spice and black pepper. Relatively full-bodied, with spice, malt and hazelnuts on the palate. The medium-length finish features ginger and fruit and nut milk chocolate. Tullibardine Distillery Visitor Centre, Pharlanne Delicatessen, 13 Bridge Street, Kelso TD5 7HT and at www.pharlanne.co.uk 40.0% ABV, 70cl, £25.00, Pharlanne, distillery website.
 http://www.whisky-pages.com/notes/distillery.php?id=queen



Personal notes on an evening of tasting

Glen Spey 21 - 2010 edition OB cask strength - potent wood spice &
highland fruit basket



Clynelish 29 Caledonia Selection 1972-2002 59.3% Incredible roses,
paraffin, complex fruits & sea air and salty pickle. The highlight of
the night - but there were many others

Bruichladdich 1970 OB 44.2% CS - Fruity & maritime, almost a twin to
the Clynelish - but slightly less floral & without the acid pickle
note.

Ben Nevis 34 1966 Black Adder Raw Cask 49.7% Unbelievable Chocolate
coffee & violets flavor signature with odd exotic incense perfume
notes. Another highlight

Bowmore 12 OB 43% bottled in 1960s or 70s w/ tax stamp for US. -
Unbelievably complex. Clams, hemp, honey, earth, old bottle mineral
notes, huge wet vinyl iodine sweet rich.. Wow! A highlight

Port Ellen 22 1982-2004 single Cask for PLOWED Douglas Liang 61.6%
Sweet dense lemons, and lemon drop candy,sea iodine, honey, road tar
turning to ash. Huge. Another highlight

Glen Grant 31 1971-2003 Black Adder Raw Cask 55.7% sherried. Black
walnuts, dark chocolate, bubble gum floral fruity sweetness, big
orchid dark floral. A stunning highlight!

Ended with a Balmonach 1961-1980 46% Cadenhead dumpy. Intense floral
incense fruit bomb. Palate was already blitzed. Should have had this
before the peat bombs.

Friday, July 27, 2012

Balvenie Tun 1401 Marries Bourbon & Sherry Casks. Batch 2 vs 5 Head ToHead

Tun 1401 Batch 5's cask list

Note: Tim Read of http://www.scotchandicecream.com/ and I are simultaneously reviewing Balvenie Tun 1401 Batch 5: our first coordinated reviewing effort. His review is at:
http://www.scotchandicecream.com/2012/07/27/a-repeat-performance-balvenie-tun-1401-batch-5

Balvenie Tun 1401 is a brilliant conception: a vatting of a number of rare old bourbon casks and sherry butts together, from different vintages for complexity. A month ago I debated the merits of bourbon versus sherry cask maturation in a post about two expressions of Springbank CS. There exists a real divide between sherried malts - which are delicious concoctions that taste of sherry with fig, prune, and dark chocolate notes - and malts aged in refill or bourbon casks which are truer to the taste of the distillate with floral and fruity esters in the fore. I became alive to the benefits of vatting these two types in a visceral and first hand way last week when I mistakenly poured a couple of glasses of unused whisky from a tasting event back into the wrong 4 oz transport bottle: I put Auchentoshan Valinch 2011 into Glenfarclas 25 at a 3 to 1 ratio. Initially horrified, I tucked it away. A few days later I took a dram and was delighted by a sweet and spirited result that was somehow more vibrant than either of its components on it's own. Lighter and more malty and floral than a sherried malt and more jammy and rich than the bourbon malt by itself. The whole in this fortuitous mix is greater than the sum of its parts. In Tun 1401, beloved Balvenie Master Distiller David Stewart is doing this with superb rare old casks of Balvenie, and decades of experience, of course. And the flavor signatures of extremely mature Balvenie in both sherry bomb and fruit bomb manifestations melded is the big story here.

I'm fascinated by this conception. I'm aware of other whiskies that age in bourbon cask and finish in sherry cask - but not whiskies that specifically vat these two dominant styles to achieve... what? A happy medium? A new flavor profile? Balvenie's web site doesn't address this question. They say the inspiration was the "magical atmosphere" of a particular warehouse where the greatest casks lay for ages:

"Tun 1401 is a very special vatting from the Balvenie’s Warehouse 24, one of the oldest areas of the distillery grounds and home to some of the most special casks in Speyside. It was conceived by the Balvenie’s malt master David Stewart, who was so inspired by the magical atmosphere inside Warehouse 24, that he created Tun 1401 to capture the essence of it in a bottle."
http://www.thebalvenie.com/en-us/roadshow/2011/11/tun-1401-a-taste-of-warehouse-24-3/


Because Tun 1401 holds less than 3000 bottles worth, Stewart has made a number of batches. I first began to pine for a taste of Tun 1401 back in April when Allison Patel blogged about her visit to Balvenie with Chip Tate and how David Stewart himself gave them a tour and then poured them special drams. Tun 1401 isn't explicitly named in the text but is depicted in the dead center front of the ultimate picture. (It's Batch 2- I checked the cask listing):
http://thewhiskywoman.wordpress.com/2012/04/06/distillery-visit-balvenie-in-speyside-scotland/

Among the many reviews of Tun 1401 I subsequently read, Tim Read's tale of a skeptic won over by Batch 3 (and won over utterly completely) was the most affecting: "This is one of those rare whiskies that I can’t see how I’d change or improve."
http://www.scotchandicecream.com/2012/06/12/a-small-batch-worth-the-price/

Frankly, given that, I began to believe. But would the next batch be as good as the one Tim had?

Balvenie's web site:
"The first batch was made for distillery visitors only, and was created from 6 casks – a 1973 Sherry Butt, a 1972 Sherry Hogshead and American casks from 1966, 1974, 1978 and 1988.
Batch 2 was released only in Europe, Asia, and South Africa and is made up of 10 casks, mostly from the 1970s with one from the 1960s and one from the 1980s.
Batch 3 is a similar to batch 2, but was made for US distribution only.
Batch 4 was made for travel retail..."


"When asked how he expects the batches to differ, Mr Stewart said, “…the batches do have some similarity but if one were to line the four batches up for sampling, which I haven’t done yet, we might be surprised by the differences that there are. I think that each has this citrus orangey flavour which seems consistent…”'
http://www.thebalvenie.com/en-us/roadshow/2011/11/tun-1401-a-taste-of-warehouse-24-3/

As for Batch 5, Balvenie states:
"Crafted from nine of the rarest and most precious casks from the distillery – 4 sherry butts distilled in 1970, 1971, 1972, 1975 and 5 American oak casks from 1966, 1972, 1973, 1974 and 1991– this drop is the culmination of years of work. Our Malt Master David Stewart says:
'Working with whiskies of this age is both a delight and a challenge as their individual characteristics are so rich and complex. Five very rare crafts and a long wait have gone into making these vintage whiskies.'"

Batch 5 is limited to 2862 bottles.

However, I'm not content simply to try Batch 5. I want to try them head to head, as Stewart speculates. So I obtained a sample of the now very out of stock Batch 2 from Master of Malt (now sold out):

Balvenie Tun 1401 batch 2 50.6%


Color: golden light amber

Nose: roses, cantaloup, honeydew, honey, bee's wax, musk, spermaceti, lanolin, chalk and gypsum mineral. Drifts of fruit like citrus and fig off in the distance... A bewitching, complex, and seductive nose that hits squarely in the middle of the Highland-Speyside profile but snakes out like an octopus into distant quadrants of the aroma gamut.

Entry, sweet and green/white fruited on the tip of the tongue and then rapidly darker with sandalwood incense, oak spice, and a sudden rapid expansion of spicy heat that lingers. The heat brings a bitter and tannic note. It also brings an august sherry flavor array into the mid-palate with rancio, figs, dates, and black raisins. This august old sherry note lingers into the looonnng finish with oak tannins, incense, fruity malt

A few drops of water adds more citrus to the nose and amps up the melon sugars in the palate, which pushes the bitterness back a notch. The palate comes close to matching the glory of the nose - only misses by the margin the bitterness.


*****

This is a clear five star product. The twin natures of richly mature sherry bomb and superb extremely mature floral waxy Speyside fruit bomb are each distinct in various ways and yet are superbly married into a bold new flavor profile that is familiar and yet totally new in my experience. It is distinguished, rich, delicious, and richly dense in flavor, sweetness, heat, tannins, spice, and bitterness. It hits on all whisky cylinders.

Balvenie Tun 1401 Batch 5 50.1% abv


Tun 1401 Batch 5
Sourced from The Whisky Exchange.


Color: medium amber with gold glints

Nose: Beeswax, honey, floral honeysuckle and roses, Paraffin, warm roasted citrus, musk, some prune and fig and a complex backdrop of faint sandalwood incense

Entry: Sweet, floral, and richly honeyed but immediately complex and filigreed with oak tannins and fragrance. There is a wallop of peppery heat and cracked black pepper flavor in the midpalate expansion that rides shotgun with an emerging complex of sherry nutty vinous old Olorosso flavors of rancio, prune, fig, and dark chocolate. The sugars of the opening extend into this mid-palate pepper and sherry and give warmth and depth to the fruit and chocolate notes. At the turn to the finish the sugar fades and bitter chocolate meets rising oak tannins to produce a leather and tobacco sensation. Yet the finish isn't dominated by bitter. It is owned by sherry oak with a rich old scotch dark leather and black oak furniture vibe - like the House of Lords. I'll delight my wife, the English Professor and call it a "luxury oak" finish. The echoes in your mouth are formal and plush as if you are in the overstuffed antechamber of a rich and powerful old lawyer or politician.

This is a big big whisky, loaded with the rich mature fruit bomb and wax of Bourbon cask Speys and the big tannins and dark fruit and leather of mature sherry bombs. Of course this is exactly what this is. The genius was to marry them.

A dash of water lightens and accentuates the citrus and musk and honeysuckle melon notes and lightens and sweetens the palate. The entry becomes more honeyed and more effusively if less intensely floral. The malabar black pepper flavor and heat is unaffected while the other notes lighten. With water the flavor amplitude of this magnificent dram becomes wider and bigger. I think I prefer it with a bit of water.

Needless to say this big whisky needs s lot of time to open up. Plan on half an hour to 45 minutes before really sipping.

*****

Another winner. Another monster. I think Batch 5 has a slight edge over Batch 2 because the bitter notes in the finish are less prominent. It's a bit smoother at the back end, but a bit more aggressive with the heat in the mid-palate expansion, which I prefer. What's striking to me having them side by side is how incredibly similar they are. These are clearly the result of the same intent on the part of the blender. They are obvious kin.

I'm very excited to read Tim Read's review on http://www.scotchandicecream.com/ particularly because he said that there was a clear winner in the matchup between Batch 3 and Batch 5.  I wonder which it is?  Check out Tim's review at:

http://www.scotchandicecream.com/2012/07/27/a-repeat-performance-balvenie-tun-1401-batch-5


Update:  on repeated tasting I'm reversing my position.  Batch 2 has a more luscious nose.  Batch 5's nose is less effusive.  Batch 2 opens up and loses the bitter edge over time.  Whether Batch 5 opens more fully over time remains to be seen - but it hasn't happened yet.  Still very close.  I drank these two with a friend who has also tried Tun 1401 Batch 3 and he confirms Tim's assessment that Batch 3 is possessed of Balvenie's honeyed house style much more than either Batch 2 or Batch 5.  That's two votes for Batch 3.

Sunday, July 22, 2012

Four Roses Single Barrel 17 OBSV distillery-only issue: the brutal blind.


The intellectual, analytical, and brilliant computer geek, whisky geek, creative hooch scientist and blogger Tim Read, the creator of the blog Scotch & Ice Cream challenged me last month with a blind bourbon to taste and try to identify.  It was labeled, simply "Bourbon 55.3%"


Granted, that's a huge clue.  But searching 55.3% abv bourbons yields next to nothing.  There just aren't any regularly distributed bourbons at that strength at all - at least according to Google.  I decided to let my palate do the walking:

Tim's Blind Bourbon 55.3% abv


Color:  dark coppery amber bronze: a rich and lovely hue.  Look at the metal copper and pumpkin orange when the light of the sun shines through it:
Tim's blind bourbon is a glory of copper metal by the rails

Nose:  a soft rich bourbon nose redolent of citrus, cherry, peach, golden tobacco, and musky toffee with an august and regal acetone glow and a spicy edge to the fruit mustiness.

Entry: Sweet and fruity with black licorice then suddenly peppery.  The mid palate turns dry and bold with Virginia tobacco at the expansion & turn. There are more fruits: jujube on the finish. What a wonderful balance between fruit and heat.  Loads of black pepper.  The turn to the finish sees the black pepper maintain its burn and oak emerge, along with a measure of char and creosote.

Adding a drop of water puts orange & orange blossoms in the nose after a few minutes. Big soft august sweet entry with cherry citrus. Then a tobacco laden mid with black licorice.  Finally, gentle oak char and oak, but not a heavily wooded finish.  This is more cracked black pepper and more amazing blond Virginia tobacco than I have ever had in a spirit.  I've heard these words used to describe Bourbon, but I have never tasted them bold, detailed, and up front like this before and I LIKED IT!

I tweeted my tasting notes to Tim:
 Then, I made two guesses:

Four Roses 100th Anniversary & Wild Turkey Kentucky Legend - neither of which I had tried, but both had the high rye mash bill I was tasting and they both had the right proof.  However, I couldn't bear for it to end so I tweeted:


Tim replied "how could I know if it was Four Roses given that they have ten different mash bills with widely divergent flavor profiles.  I agreed. (I wrote about the ten mash bills in this post).

A day passed and I returned to the blind but found myself befuddled and confused.  I forgot about my high-rye conclusion and got stuck on the idea that maybe Tim was trying to psych me out with the new Pappy 15 - which supposedly tastes more spicy than usual wheaters.  Never mind it's the wrong proof... I tweeted:

Then I floundered, suggested the Pappy hypothesis without making a definite guess, then ended weak.:


Note - Tim corrected this to 17 years a little bit later.

First - a couple of lessons for me about blind tasting: 1) Trust your instincts and your first impressions.  2) Don't listen to the voice telling you it might be a trick. The one psyching out is yourself.  How close had I come in my first guesses?  Well Four Roses 100th Anniversary is a 17 year old single barrel bourbon with the mash bill OBSV.  And Tim's blind?  Same exact story: a 17 year old single barrel bourbon from Four Roses with the mash bill OBSV.  This particular one is a distillery-only offering.  Tim wrote up a post about it with tasting notes and the conclusion:


"Quality-wise, I have to say that this particular barrel (78-30, Warehouse QS), honestly stands shoulder to shoulder with other highly regarded bourbons like those found in the Buffalo Trace Anniversary Collection; Pappy Van Winkle, or the Parker’s Heritage collection. Honestly, I think if Four Roses could find the right push for this one, they could release these in limited quantities to a broader market and have a serious contender for the Van Winkles of the world, which are becoming a chore to find anymore."
http://www.scotchandicecream.com/2012/07/06/four-roses-obsv-part-two-extra-aged-bourbon/

I find myself substantially in agreement.  This is a superb bourbon, with a delicious, strong, and unusual flavor profile.  It drinks younger than its advanced age, but achieves something unique.  Could Four Roses make this a regular expression?  I have no idea - but it clearly would be a popular issue.  Thanks so much, Tim for giving me a taste of something unusual and for taking me on a wild ride!

Note:  This is the 3rd single barrel expression from Four Roses I've formally reviewed on this blog.  The other two are:
1) The standard 50 % abv OBSV:
http://www.cooperedtot.com/2012/04/four-roses-single-barrel-100-proof.html
2) A Park Avenue Liquors exclusive 53.6% OBSQ:
http://www.cooperedtot.com/2012/02/four-roses-single-barrel-is.html

Mortlach 22 yo Gordon & MacPhail for Sestante: time traveling to 1971 or before.

Mortlach is one of the oldest distilleries in Speyside, founded in 1823 (the same year as Glenlivet) in Dufftown.  It has a fascinating history (which I recommend you read on the excellent Malt Madness site here).  Mortlach is yet another of those distilleries that you mainly find in independent bottler editions. It rarely appears in its own label.  Most of its output ends up in Johnny Walker Black Label (yes, another whole distillery poured into the vast sea of square black bottles).  Have I mentioned that I really like Johnny Walker Black Label?  The essential feature for me in this history is that floor maltings continued through 1968 and direct fired stills were in operation through 1971.  This means that distillates prior to 1969 should be made in the old traditional Speyside manner - before mechanization and the homogenization that Oliver Klimek describes so elegantly in his though provoking article "Has Whisky Become Better, Worse or Just Different"  That 1971-1968 period feels so close - so in reach.

That's why I stopped when I saw this listing in the Whisky Samples web site:

Image of Mortlach 22yo (40%, Gordon&MacPhail, 75cl, Sestante Import, bottled before 1993)Mortlach 22yo (40%, Gordon&MacPhail, 75cl, Sestante Import, bottled before 1993)

This should have been bottled pré 1993 as the 75cl bottle is sealed by an Italian tax label in red/orange with 2 stars. 

http://whiskysamples.flyingcart.com/index.php?p=detail&pid=802&cat_id=

"Well," I thought, "that's distilled in 1971 at the latest - the era of direct fired stills.  If it's even a few years older than that, it might be the real deal."  Plus it had the allure of the "Sestante" name.  Allure?  Yes, I'm fascinated by the defunct independent bottler Sestante.  It might be silly to be enamored of obscure Italian independent bottlers, but this one isn't around any more, so it's yet another layer of unobtanium.  I couldn't resist.  What was I hoping for?  A taste of a vanished world, with complexity, sweetness & oak and whiff of smoke and maybe even a distant taste of peat, like the Dylan Thomas poem "A Child's Christmas in Wales" takes you back to a vanished world.  I was looking to time travel with this dram.  But it wasn't a sure thing.

Mortlach 22 yo Gordon & MacPhail Sestante bottled prior to 1993. 40% abv


Color: very dark amber w/coppery tints - like old bourbon.

Nose: A rapid evolution from sweet cherry bubble gum at first pour to, as it opens up, big intense dried figs, honey, dark old rum, cherry preserves, ripe persimmons, old oak drawers, dust, and old parchment. A huge august mature sherry bomb aroma.

The entry is robust sherry, a firm oloroso note with jammy raisin, plum, and maraschino notes giving way to sharp tannic bite.  With extra air time citrus flavors and sharp citric acids emerge through the dark chocolate dank prune. The mid palate is spicy with sandalwood incense resiny oak essence and a hint of distant smoke. There is a big tannic pucker at the finish and some dank oak bitterness to go with it. This is a hyper mature sherry bomb with a dense old time feel - like antique whisky - which in a sense it might really be.  The current dilution to 40% renders mouth feel light & silky, sadly, not honey thick like it should be. I didn't dare add water.

Ultimately it's a big and luscious dram but a tad unbalanced in the direction of dark and tannic.  Yet that somehow suited my fantasy.  The flavor signature reminded me, yet again (as many of these old Spey and Highland drams do) of a formative experience with a whole bottle of 1980s Balvenie coat of arms flagon no age statement back in my early days with Scotch.  It had an over-oaked intensity and a complex and almost noble rot quality that feels like "antique".  Indeed it smells a bit like an antique furniture shop or a visit to an old European palace.  Bottom line, this one took me there and I was reveling in the wild progression of a rainbow of old oak flavors and scents melded to big old sherry.  Not the last word is deliciousness, perhaps, but a fine choice to transport you to another time.

















FYI - in looking over where I had been I came across Ruben's notes for an old Sestante labelled bottle of Mortlach 20 from the 1980s that would certainly have been made in the floor malting days.  His tasting notes are an eerie twin to mine.  This helps confirm my impression that this was similar stuff:

"Nose: old-style sherry with a thick liqueur-like character. Lots of old polished oak and leather. Old books and incense. A very soft smokiness too. Raisins, a hint of caramel maybe. Also a sweet beefy note and burnt fruit cake. Mouth: dry, pretty oaky (a tad too much for my taste). There’s still an underlying dark sweetness of sultanas, but it grows resinous and herbal as well, with a slight sourness. Again some smoke in the distance. Feels nicely old but maybe a bit past its prime. Finish: long, dry, still some herbal notes, oak and smoke.
A nice experience but you’ll have to stand some old oak and herbs. It’s closer to a Mortlach 1936 for example than to recent expressions."
http://www.whiskynotes.be/2012/mortlach/mortlach-20-years-sestante/