|The map of the Cognac Cru regions from the wiki article on Cognac|
Most cognacs have a much narrower range of variation in flavor profile than scotch does (although the wider world of brandies has considerably more variation than you'll find in Cognac alone - including some lovely leather and fig Spanish, refined sweet South African, and very distinctive Armenian ones). However the sweep of variation from bad cognac to really nice cognac is breathtaking. So, sadly, is the hype and marketing goo goo. Ranging from pseudo-imperial French pretension with a predilection for insanely expensive bottle materials (i.e. gold, platinum, uber crystal etc...) to a weird contemporary hip-hop connection, the way Cognac is sold can be stomach turning in my opinion. Nevertheless, the issue is, as always, what's in the glass when the gauzy models, leather clad rappers, and fancy packaging are left behind and out of mind.
Tonight I'll be looking at a few of the the market leading cognacs across the age and region spectrum to take a quick survey of the segment. The purpose here is to see 1) do I really notice or care about the differences among VS, VSOP, and XO, 2) to sample a few of the major brand leaders. The 4 leaders in Cognac are Remy Martin, Courvoisier, Hennesy, and Martel. Together they sell about 90% of all the Cognac sold world-wide. 3) I wanted to throw in a fairly inexpensive domestic brandy to see if it could compete. A single data point isn't definitive - but it's better than nothing. I chose E&J VSOP because it was handy and regular E&J was the dominant quaff in my childhood home in California. Clearly I should have chosen something else (and will in the future). Here we go:
Courvoisier VS 40% abv - lacks the Cru region statement that the other Courvoisier's have. $34/750ml (prices all from Shopper's Vineyard in Clifton, NJ - right near me)
Color: coppery gold (light orange)
Nose: Marmelade, honey, some light sandalwood - pretty weak.
Mouthfeel is very light. Entry is sweet with vanilla and a vinous simple sugar note with a prominent sawdust wood note with an incense perfume aspect (patchouli). Midpalate expansion is mainly a mild spirit heat. There's not much depth here. Finish is very short, mainly spirit heat - but also some wood in the fade-out. It doesn't suffer from the turpentine burn of bad brandy - that's the upside; just from a lack of depth of flavor.
Hennessy VS 40% abv: $30/750ml
Color: orangey amber - also lacks a Cru region statement.
Nose: Light sandalwood / patchouli incense perfume is the dominant lead off note. Slight citrus note, but not much else past all the incense.
Like the Courvoisier VS, entry is sweet and light - dominated by a sweet simple sugar vinous note and a burst of fresh sawn wood with a patchouli incense flavor. Spirit heat is even more present here than with the Couvoisier VS in the midrange. This stuff is hot. There's a little hint of the turpentine notes. Ironically, the finish is a little longer with some nice almond notes, less bitterness than the Courvoisier VS in the finish, and some nice oak.
Remy Martin VSOP 40% abv. - all the grapes come from Grand and Petit Champagne. $40/750ml
Color: orangey amber
Nose: nice jammy orange, honey, dates, prunes, figs, and black currants initially. There's a little oak wood sandalwood perfume. Noticeably absent are floral notes. With time, the intensity of the nose fades, unfortunately. Still, what lingers is pleasant. I could nose this for a while.
Entry is vinously sweet, spicy and a bit woody. Midpalate broadens into tasty sherry notes, vanilla floral notes and big oak spice. The finish is medium in length with lovely fading cabernet with some nice grape seed astringency. With extended time the mouth feel becomes a bit thin but the flavor profile is pretty tasty and distinguished. It's not intense - but it presents the clear strong flavors of grape spirit, oak sugars, and oak wood notes.
Courvoisier VSOP 40% abv - a "Fine Champagne" meaning over half the grapes come from the Champagne region. $38/750ml
Color: orangey amber
Nose: jammy citrus and candied orange peel. Blackberries, walnuts, red currants.
Entry is sweet and a bit spicy. There's vanilla and a nice cognac jam-like citrus and grape rancio taste. Midpalate expansion is hot (a sign of young spirits mixed in). Mouthfeel is light - belying the darker color. Finish is medium short with spirit heat, rather than oak driving. There are some vanilla and oak notes in the finish that are clearly part of the good cognac flavor profile. However there's too much admixing of lower quality spirits here. This is a disappointment.
[Update: the following day I drank another sample of this and enjoyed it better. Lighter, less spicy, less flavor dense, and rounder than Remy or Frapin, it still was flavorful and nice to quaff. I stand by my original assessment - that Courvoisier VSOP comes last comparison with Remy Martin VSOP and Frapin VSOP - but "a disappointment" is a bit too harsh. It's not unpleasant to drink.]
Frapin VSOP 40% - all the grapes come from Grand Champagne Cru - specifically the Frapin estates. $62/750ml
Color: light orangey amber
Nose: crystallized orange, faint citrus flowers, cognac spirit, sultanas, distant oak. The best nose of the VSOPs in this segment.
Entry is sweet with white raisin grapey syrup. There is glory and rich mouthfeel in the sweet thrill of this opening. Midpalate blooms quickly with jammy citrus notes of orange and lemon, spirit heat as peppery boldness, and also a confectionery candy quality with somewhat faint floral overtones of honeysuckle and jasmine. In the transition to the finish things rapidly darken as floral oak turns to tannin bite. This emerging bitter note meshes well with the crystalized orange as an candy orange rind feeling. Finish is moderately long with a cilantro note in the back of the throat at the fade out and lingering vinous sap.
Frapin Chateau Fontpinot XO - all the grapes come from the single plantation at the Chateau Fontpinot in the heart of the Grand Champagne Cru. $105/750ml at Park Ave, $90 on line.
Color: dark orangey amber - henna tints
Nose: august floral vanilla with a big floral component that includes honeysuckle and some rose notes. Confection in the form of marzipan (candied almond paste), plus darker nuts (walnuts or hazelnuts), and dark caramel. There's a big wood perfume aspect too: oak, and sandalwood. This is a rich and luscious nose that you can bury yourself in for literally hours.
Entry is rich with dark burgundy, quince, black figs, and plum/prune flavors, The midrange expansion brings in tobacco, walnut skin, and sandalwood perfume. The finish is long and dominated by vanilla, sandalwood oak perfume, and rancio (grape noble rot with cheese-like overtones). It's a rich and heady pudding.
Clearly Frapin Chateau Fontpinot XO needs to be considered among other XOs. The purpose of putting it here was to represent the class and see if it clearly outclasses the other offerings. The answer is yes, indeed - and how. This stuff is a whole different ball game.
E&J VSOP Brandy 40% abv - from Modesto California. $10/750ml
California grows some of the best wine grapes in the world, so the brandy ought to be excellent, however the leaders, Korbel and E&J never did it for me. I haven't tried Germain-Robin, which is well reviewed. I figured I'd give E&J's upscale "VSOP" variant a try:
Nose: orange creamsickle
Entry note is cough syrup. Chemically, medicinal, and gripped by an artificial orangy flavor. This is going right down the drain.
FYI - the base expression of E&J was better. See my review here:
So, let's review: the two VS offerings were light, hot, and unbalanced in that they had too much patchouli incense and spirit heat and not enough body, complexity in the sweetness up front or the nose, and enough wood in the finish. They weren't undrinkable; but I'm not going to seek VSes out. At $30-35 they don't compete with bourbons or even Scotch in this price range. In the VSOPs things are different. There are VSOPs that satisfy and compete successfully with bourbons and Scotches of comparable price. Remy is less floral and citrusy than the Frapin VSOP, but doesn't strike any off notes. Given that Remy VSOP goes for $40 around here and Frapin VSOP goes for over $60, that's fine. The Frapin VSOP is close to entry level XOs in quality and price - and is more a transitional form between VSOP and XO. Part of its expense is that it is composed solely of Grand Champagne grapes. Frapin VSOP was the best of the VSOPs in this test, but Remy VSOP isn't embarrassed by the the Frapin VSOP at only 2/3rds the price. Furthermore, Remy VSOP has superior mouth feel, flavor density, and balance to Couvoisier VSOP which is very close to the same price. The less said about E&J "VSOP" brandy the better. The sole XO here, Frapin Chateau Fontpinot, stole the show and is a highlight experience. I'd have to say it represents excellent value at its relatively high price. Spirits that cost in the vicinity of $100 should wow you. This one absolutely does.
Bottom line Remy Martin VSOP is very much the winner here in the mid-range price segment. I learned that I like the best quality (surprise, surprise). But for an everyday Cognac, Remy Martin VSOP is like Johnny Walker Black Label - it comes close to a stylistic archetype via extensive blending and achieves that at a very realistic price. Cognac is enjoyable and satisfying when you spend long green to get special examples. But Cognac is also enjoyable and satisfying at mid-level prices too.