Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Woodford Reserve Bourbon - Lithe and balanced, Woodford is a polished sophisticated bourbon


Woodford Reserve has a cult following and it's easy to understand why: it has a lean, semi-dry, aspect that emphasizes herbal and botanical notes and downplays the resiny fruity "candy corn"'aspect one often finds in bourbons. It is sophisticated and grown up hooch for more discriminating palates.
Woodford is a lovely medium amber color - darker than Makers or Beam but lighter than lighter than, say Kentucky Spirit or Craig 18. It's lovely. Nose is full of toffee walnut and tobacco. There's some leather and cream too. First sip opens bright with brown sugar and honeyed corn. Vanilla notes from oak arrive shortly and the midpalate blooms with herbal and floral aspects that mute the sweetness combined with the leather and tobacco meets toffee aspect. Finish is medium long and a bit dry with oak vanilla floral qualities and a kiss of distant smoke. It's a very tasty experience - if lacking the depth of flavor of the very best. The absence of "corn likker" fruitiness is most appreciated. This is a good bourbon for convincing scotch drinkers to consider bourbon.

****

Glenmorangie Nectar D'Or - Floral, honeyed; light as feather yet rich and delightful

Bill Lumsden of Glenmorangie distillery pioneered the practice of unconventional secondary wood cask finishing for Scotch over a decade ago. It has become a general trend - to the benefit of us all. Nectar D'or is the from the more refined second generation of secondary wood finished whiskeys from Glenmorangie. It's a honey - right in the price/performance sweet spot. In this case Sauterne casks are used for aging after bourbon oak.
Nose is sweet and floral with tons of vanilla and honeysuckle. Entry is rich and sweet with a bit of citrus and cerial/treacle sugar. Midpalate bursts with honey and honeysuckle, mitigated by an herbal, almost lemony aspect. Adding a tiny drop of pure water sends the perfume aspect skyward. I have never tasted a more floral scotch whiskey. The vanilla notes from the oak come to the fore in the extremely long and complex finish. There are wood notes, a creeping dryness in the finish that adds sophisticated to sweet honeysuckle front loaded presentation.

This is not a macho scotch. It's utterly French Baroque in it's fancy gilding, filigree and floral exuberance. Totally delicious, unique, and special. A tour de force from Lumsden and a bargain at the price.

*****

Elijah Craig 18 - Dark, sweet, old, complex bourbon: a gourmet treat

Elijah Craig 18 is, in my opinion, one of the finest bourbons available. Single barrel, unadulterated, unmessed with and aged into a rich indulgent woodiness - this is the real deal; an American classic.  It comes from a low rye corn heavy mash bill; the same as used in Evan Williams black label and a number of other Heaven Hill products.  However extensive aging and barrel selection has allowed this EC18 to rise to the top like cream.  It tastes like a whole different animal.

In the glass - a dark dark amber with a gleaming copper core. The nose is rich with toffee / butterscotch, oak, caramel corn, vanilla perfume, sherry, and cognac. Let it sit for 10-20 minutes to bloom before sipping.  More aromas keep coming out and the sweetness is amplified in the taste.

 On entry there is sweetness: red and yellow fruits, maybe even some tropical fruits from the papaya and pineapple end of the spectrum, leather, floral vanilla and burnt caramel. By midpalate a dryness has crept in fueled by wood tannins. The oak is in the vanilla notes and also a perfume of sandalwood that emerges into the finish. The finish is looong and huge with leather, burnt caramel again, vanilla and sandalwood perfume. There's a rich heaviness to the mouth feel.  The mix of sweet and dry is sophisticated and luscious.  The whole affair is loaded, like a dense tropical rainforest.  But the flavors are very accessible and the overall feel is sweet and easy; an aspect to which I credit the high corn mash bill. 

This is amazing bourbon and a steal at the price. My advice: never mix this. Never put water or ice in it. Let it air and sip it neat and slow.  Time is this bourbon's friend.  Time in the barrel, time in the glass.  I find that I keep coming back to it over time too.  It's a sinful guilty pleasure that hits all my bourbon buttons.  You might not impress bourbon snobs by serving it, but you might find that you can convert people who don't drink bourbon with it.  It's an undeniably higher quality class of liquor.  Factor in price and it's one of the strongest cases out there.

*****

Angels Envy - Port wood finish on a nice light Heaven Hill bourbon: Angels Envy is something new

Angels Envy is a fine bourbon from Heaven Hill distillery that has been given a secondary aging in port wood casks, after the aging in charred new oak casks as the law requires for bourbon. The color is light medium amber - like Evan Williams.   Evan Williams is the best known Heaven Hill bourbon - and its a sweet mild bourbon - like what's under the port perfumed hood of Angel's Envy. Unlike Evan Williams there is a rosy glow. Here follows my tasting notes:
Nose after 10 minutes: Buttered corn, spirit, molasses and biscuits. Entry is smooth and mostly dry. Flavor is muted. Midpalate opens up broadly with oak, leather, and a gentle grain sweetness with plenty of spirit warmth. Finish is medium long with red fruit joining the biscuit grain. There's a hint of distant smoke and some mineral tones and country grass at the finish. The whole presentation is sinewy and sophisticated; lean rather than sweet and fat like I was expecting.

The lightness; the low density of flavor here is tad disappointing to me. But the flavor that is present is very good. This tastes just like a good bourbon that only rested 4 years - which is exactly what it is. The port finish is very slight - just a hint. I think this whole show will be better and more impressive with more time in the wood. In the meantime, it's quite nice now. A very credible effort at something new for American whisky (this secondary wood finish is a mature trend in Scotch Whiskey).  However, factor in price (around $50 here in NYC) and it's a tough sell.  There are a number of alternatives that offer far more enjoyment for the money, in my opinion.

Port Charlotte 7 - Titanic explosion of flavor - weird and wonderful

Port Charlotte is a wannabe reincarnated distillery project from Jim McEwan, the mercurial genius behind the new incarnation of Bruichladdich. The malts from the Port Charlotte project all date from since when McEwan took over. They are intended to be his peated expression and peated they are. The Port Charlotte series began with a 5 year old version (PC5) that quickly became legend. The next year the expression was six years old and was called PC6 and so on until 9. I've tried PC7 and PC8 and they are among the most powerful, intensely flavored spirits I have ever tasted. The PC8 is strikingly different from the PC7 on offer here - a more yellow color, more vanilla from the oak, a more mellow peat profile. My understanding is that each year is quite distinct. They are all very young heavily peated Islay malts bottled at a searing young cask strength.
The PC7 is golden with a rosy peachy blush. When the bottle is first opened the first few drams have a very odd nose of library paste, solvent, and pork rinds - even after 15 minutes in the glass. Over time (weeks) the interaction with air mellows the nose and the solvent fades away and the library paste becomes more of an old book aroma and iodine, (the pork rinds remain). It's an odd nose - and if that was the end of the story I wouldn't have fallen in love. Entry is explosive with bean and grain sweetness joining an intense honeyed smokiness and brine and kippers. The finish is intensely long with fresh sawn wood, smoke, sea and turf joining the honey grain and smoked fish and spirity heat. The explosion of flavors is unusually intense and I want more right away. However the mouth sear from the high proof makes me slow down and have a drink of water every 3rd or 4th sip. Early on this intense young cask strength heat made me tempted to put water in it. Doing so cuts the heat but also dilutes the intense sweet salty smoke intensity that wows me. I opt for interspersing sips of water to cut the fire in my mouth and take this whisky neat.

Ultimately - extraordinary. More densely flavored than any whisky I've ever tasted. The odd nose is forgiven in the face of the rich Islay malt flavor. Wonderful - but very very strong meat.

*****

Jim Beam Red Stag Bourbon - Utterly delicious neat and born to be mixed

For the record, I'm not a liqueur drinker. I'm a whiskey drinker who prefers single malt scotch and single barrel bourbon neat, never anywhere near ice and aired for 10 minutes before first sip after well sniffing in a small cylindrical glass. I was expecting to HATE Red Stag - but it seduced me because it puts the taste of bourbon first. It smells like bourbon with a hint of cherry pipe tobacco in the glass: notes of popcorn, molasses, tobacco, leather, and cherry. At first sip the first taste is bourbon: corn, honey, bacon, and molasses. The mid palate explodes with cherry and tobacco and leather. It's sweet, but it's oddly sophisticated. The finish is sweet with honey, cherry, and smoke.
It's utterly delicious. I polished off my glass like a hungry wolf. The cherry is robust - but tastes real. It never obscures the bourbon which shines through with character, age, and American cowboy splendor like Johnny Cash's voice.

I'm a whiskey snob, but this liqueur is the only whiskey adulteration I've ever loved. The cherry bourbon alchemy is killer mixed with coke. It's even better in a modified Manhattan. I suspect it will work in any mixed drink where bourbon plays a part and you'd consider putting in a cherry.

Why only 4 stars? I love this stuff - but I'm a whiskey purist and this isn't pure whiskey.  It's an adulteration and displays a liqueur's syrupy sweetness, thick sugary mouth feel, and a candy fruit intensity of flavor that's alien to real whiskey.  By all rights I ought to hate this... Yes... where's my glass? I want more... ****